Childless mothers
i’ve used the phrase “childless mother” to describe myself in the past, and it is often met with “huh?”s and “what do you mean?”s. So I thought I’d take the initiative and explain it early on
What is a childless mother? Well, in this case it’s not anything you’d find if you Googled the term (which I just did). I’m not a bereaved mother who had a child(ren) that died. I’m not an incarcerated mother. I’m not a biological mother who gave her child up for adoption. I’m not an adoptive mother whose child was given back to its biological mother. I’m not a woman who has been pregnant and lost her baby to miscarriage or stillbirth.
Simply put, I’m a wanna-be.
I’ve never been pregnant- though not for lack of trying, believe me. I have buckets of baby clothes littering my living space, unused strollers and crib sets stored in boxes, lists of names that my husband and I have gone over and over and over again. I’ve read “What To Expect When You’re Expecting”. I’m a bigger expert on prenatal care, childbirth, and childcare than my sister and cousins who really DO have kids. I even own a single, sad maternity shirt, that I bought at a KMart like six years ago and immediately felt ashamed about.
To the average person, I am no kind of mother. There is no real word for what I am in the English language. Supposedly, I’m an “infertile woman”… but there is so much more to the experience as a person who wants children and can’t have them than plain old infertility. “Infertile” doesn’t begin to cover it! There is no word for that feeling that “I AM a mother, dammit, the kids just aren’t here yet!”.
In short, I’m one of the never-beens, the ones who “don’t really understand”, who “should feel lucky (we’ve) never had one”, or who “should feel lucky (we’ve) never had one and lost it” (I suppose the latter could be true, depending on who you ask and how you look at it). To the world outside of those experiencing infertility, we’re like little girls playing house, and they treat us accordingly.
I cannot entirely blame them, though. I guess it does sound a little strange to try to explain that sometimes your body and brain and soul don’t sync up, and you can feel like a parent without ever making a child or signing a paper to take custody of one.
So. I hereby declare that you ignore all the other uses of this term- “childless mothers”- for I am stealing it to exclusively describe ladies like me. It’s now for the women who’ve wanted yet never had so much as a false positive, or a blip on the pregnancy test. For those of us who have never spent even one wonderful, happy day wondering in whispers “am I? Could I be???”. For any woman who has cried hugging a babydoll, or literally felt like running away from your cousin and her toddlers, or who had to sit through one more relative’s baby shower and couldn’t explain that she was happy and sad and jealous all at once, or who had to suffer through yet another friend or family member’s well-meaning-yet-heart-ripping “enjoy your freedom!” speech. All the while feeling tortured by that weird maternal feeling that shouldn’t even be there. She feels so, so ready for it all- everything in her life is lined up and waiting with baited breath for those children. She already FEELS like a mother- she is a mother in her soul. And yet the children never come.
That’s what a childless mother is. If you meet one, be nice to her. And be nice to the childless fathers out there, too- they do exist.
Now we just need a secret handshake!
November 3, 2007 at 9:33 am
Your post really resonanted with me. Good luck in your journey of creating your family, from one childless mother to another.
November 4, 2007 at 7:35 pm
Any luck on the handshake? Because I too am a member of the Childless Mother’s Club.
November 6, 2007 at 6:58 pm
I’m in the club, too. And I hate it.
I think our secret handshake is an empty one. Because that’s how we feel.
November 8, 2007 at 7:05 pm
Interesting post. “Childless Mother” was my second choice name for the blog I recently started, although our definitions differ slightly. I love the poem in your other post. Have you read “Childless Mother” by Louise C. Taylor?
November 15, 2007 at 1:44 pm
I cannot believe I found someone who describes perfectly everything I have always felt. I love this post.
December 3, 2007 at 1:58 am
Well said Kriss.
December 11, 2007 at 3:58 pm
Ah this struck a chord. I loved this post it so helped me today I feel so alone in this problem. So helpful were your words in what I feel as a very lonely place to be a childless mother. Timely hearing these words after my latest visit to the gynecologist. She offered to take out my uterous today, so I did not dare ask her further questions about my fertility, as clearly she thought my chances just as good if it where there or not
Of those who tell me I am better off they are truely trying to help.
I am more tired of the thoughtless “oh you never wanted kids then ?”
Should it be equally acceptable to say “So you never wanted to be good looking ?” or “so you never wanted to be wealthy ?”
February 18, 2008 at 3:10 am
my wife and I are 47 and 49 and want a child of our own. I had (male) surgery to no avail.
childless mother and childless father are perfect term.
February 27, 2008 at 12:59 am
I just celebrated my 44 birthday and my heart is breaking because I never managed to have children. Although I’m almost a step-mother and my live in boyfriend has 50% custody, something I thought would fill the “childless mother” void, it’s actually made the loss feel greater. I appreciate what you wrote and feel better knowing I’m not alone. I guess now all that’s left is to grieve so that I might someday appreciate what I do have.
March 18, 2008 at 12:17 pm
I chanced upon this page after doing a Google search on the Rilke poem “You Who Never Arrived.” Reading your poignant post brought tears to my eyes. I, too, was a “childless mother” for years. I had college degrees in Child Development & Family Relationships– I was a child care instructor, as well as a daycare director, spending my days caring for the infants, toddlers, and preschoolers of others– and each evening I went home with empty arms. After 9 years of marriage, my prayers were unexpectedly answered when I became pregnant and gave birth to a beautiful daughter. There hasn’t been a day in the 20 years since that she hasn’t been a joyful blessing, but that kind of soulful pain experienced while still longing and waiting for her will never be forgotten.